- 2023: Chase Fahnestock
- 2022: Chase Fahnestock
- 2021: Doug Doll Jr.
- 2020: Kevin Scholl
- 2019: Tom Slater
- 2018: Don Bangs
- 2017: Amanda Boicesco
- 2016: Chase Fahnestock
- 2015: Ash Senft
- 2014: Don Bangs
- 2013: Tom Boyle
- 2012: Joey Cambria
- 2011: Jeff Livezey Jr. / Joey Cambria (Co-Champs)
- 2010: Jeff Livezey Jr.
- 2023: Bob Phillips
- 2022: George Donhauser
- 2021: Hank Smith
- 2020: Hank Smith
- 2019: Iggie Boicesco
- 2018: Nick Olt
- 2017: George Smith
- 2016: Don Knoblick
- 2015: Earl Nichols Jr.
- 2014: Matt Schurman
- 2013: Earl Nichols Jr.
- 2012: Tom Goldman
- 2011: Tom Goldman
- 2010: Iggie Boicesco
- 2009: Earl Nichols Jr.
- 2008: Iggie Boicesco
- 2007: Iggie Boicesco
- 2023: Dom Burgese
- 2022: Keith Mayers
- 2021: Keith Mayers
- 2020: Keith Mayers
- 2019: Keith Mayers
- 2018: Dom Burgese
- 2017: Martin Ganjoin
- 2016: Keith Mayers
- 2015: Keith Mayers
- 2014: Keith Mayers
- 2013: Jimmy Stack